Mega Cheddar Cheese Toastie
- Preparation Time10 mins
- Cooking Time10 mins
Preheat a skillet over medium heat. Mix the butter, mayo and smoked paprika in a small bowl until well combined. Sprinkle with salt and pepper.
Lightly butter one side of each of the bread slices with the mayo mixture. Add the cream cheese to the remaining mayo mixture and mix well to combine. Spread some of the cream cheese mixture on the other side of each of the bread slices.
Distribute the Cheddar on the cream cheese-side of 4 of the bread slices. Place the remaining 4 bread slices on top. Place the sandwiches in the skillet and cook until golden on the bottom, about 3 minutes. Flip the sandwiches and place a heavy-bottomed skillet on top of the sandwiches and cook until golden brown and the cheese is melted, about 4 minutes.
Recipe courtesy of Melissa d'Arabian
Other recipes with cheese
Grilled Corn on the Cob with Garlic Butter, Fresh Lime and Cotija Cheese
Big Triple Cheese Burgers on Buttery Brioche
30 Minute Shepherd's Pie
Smoked Gouda and Leek Tart
Parmigiano Reggiano Cheese and Asparagus Tart
Chocolate Cheesecake Brownies
Lamb Chops with Mint-Walnut Pesto
Lyle's® Easter Egg Cake Pops
Wild Alaska Salmon with Sun-dried Tomato
Welsh Wine, Goat's Cheese, Leek and Parma Ham Tart
Broccoli Cheese Soup
Pork chops stuffed with sun-dried tomatoes and spinach
Quinoa Salad with Apricots, Basil and Pistachios
Prosciutto-Wrapped Grilled Brie with Pineapple
Kale and Farro Salad with Aged Goat Cheese
Chocolate Guinness Cake
Chocolate Stout Cupcakes
Irish Grilled Cheese
Easy Key Lime Ice Cream Meringue Cheesecake
Diners, Drive-Ins, And Dives
Guy Fieri takes a cross-country road trip to visit some of America's classic "greasy spoon" restaurants that have been doing it right for decades.
Man V. Food
A culinary tour across America, checking out the best diners, looking for great food and tackling the nation's largest and most fiery eating challenges.
Spring Baking Championship
Top bakers compete in exciting challenges inspired by the beauty of spring.
When restaurant owners suspect employees of not doing their jobs, or generally doing lousy work, they call in the Mystery Diners. What will they find?
Turning a failing restaurant around is a daunting task under the best of circumstances; attempting to do it in just two days and with a limited budget seems an impossible task. But chef Robert Irvine is ready to take on the challenge.
The Pioneer Woman
Award winning blogger and former city girl Ree Drummond shares her special brand of home cooking, from throw-together meals to elegant creations.
James Martin's French Adventure
James Martin takes a road trip to explore the very best in French cuisine.
Best Baker In America
Skilled bakers are challenged to use their style and technical abilities to make stunning, tasty treats. The baker that impresses the judges the most takes home a cash prize and the title of Best Baker in America.
Bizarre Foods: Delicious Destinations
Chef Andrew Zimmern discovers the legendary foods that define a location.
Holiday Baking Championship
Eight bakers show off their family traditions and superb baking skills. They must prove their abilities in front of judges Nancy Fuller, Duff Goldman and Lorraine Pascale.
The Hairy Bikers' Chicken & Egg
The Hairy Bikers hunt for the world’s greatest chicken and egg recipes.
Buddy Vs. Duff
Top bakers Buddy Valastro and Duff Goldman compete in a series of challenges to test their culinary expertise and end one of the greatest feuds in baking history. Who will win the ultimate showdown and take a slice of victory?
Barefoot Contessa: Back To Basics
Self-taught cooking queen, Ina Garten, shares her delicious, simple and unique recipes. Her dishes are perfect for celebrations and family dinners.
Girl Meets Farm
Cookbook author and food blogger, Molly Yeh, makes delicious dishes inspired by her Jewish and Chinese heritage in her farmhouse kitchen in the Midwest.
Delivery: High-End at Home
Guy and Hunter invite three chefs to prepare restaurant-quality finest at home using Flavor Market’s finest ingredients. Who will win?
Ainsley cooks dishes inspired by the delights of the seaside. Plus, he joins expert forager Alysia Vasey to find out what edible treats are growing on our shorelines.
Delivery: DDD Guilty Pleasures
Guy and Hunter Fieri send GGG delivery boxes to three chefs competing in their own joints to see who makes the best guilty pleasures. Who will win?
Mary is given special access to see how Heathrow Airport’s restaurants feed the millions of busy passengers who pass through the terminals each year.
Mary visits London’s West End to discover the secrets to feeding busy commuters and demanding tourists. Her first stop is to try traditional pastries at a famous bakery.
Delivery: All-Star Noodles
Three all-star chefs compete in a home kitchen noodle competition. Each chef flips a coin to determine whether they use high or low-priced items.
Mary boards one of the Royal Navy’s mightiest warships, the HMS Defender. As the crew take part in a war training exercise, Mary helps out the hard-working kitchen team.
Mary explores the bustling food markets in Marrakech, Morocco. Back in the kitchen, she prepares lamb tagine, a spicy carrot hummus and a fresh summer salad.
Guy and Hunter Fieri turn three GGG judges into competitors in their own kitchens. Each chef receives the ingredients to make a lumberjack breakfast.
Mary is in Dorset to attend her first-ever music festival! She explores the variety of food stalls on offer and later rocks out on stage with singer Rick Astley.
Mary begins her culinary adventure in Rome, where she witnesses some speedy pasta makers in action. Plus, she meets a daring chef who has reinvented the traditional pizza.
Brooklyn, New York
Casey Webb’s quest takes him to Brooklyn for a barbeque and deli feast. Plus, he samples an Italian seafood staple and takes on a spicy shrimp challenge.
Newark, New Jersey
Casey Webb heads to go home state, New Jersey! He samples an iconic Italian hot dog, a Portuguese pork sandwich and takes part in a taco challenge.
Delivery: DDD OGs
Guy and Hunter Fieri send out a big box of groceries to three diner chefs. They must make a classic takeaway dish using an unusual kitchen gadget.
The Northern Plains
The seven bakers put their own spin on South Dakota’s kuchen. Then for the bake-off challenge they make a new dessert with Minnesota’s scotcheroo ingredients.
From Europe To Asia
Guy finds righteous ramen in Millcreek, Utah, artichoke parmesan soup in Grand Junction, Colorado, and stuffed cabbage and schnitzel in Albuquerque, New Mexico.
Delivery: One Box Only
Guy and Hunter send only one box of groceries to three winning chefs. They must use the same 15 items in both a hot lunch and Sunday supper.
Delivery: All-Star Holiday
Guy and Hunter recruit three all-star chefs to play holiday games in their home kitchens. The chefs must cook up two different seasonal dishes.
Delivery: All-Star Hanukkah
Guy and his son, Hunter send ingredients and food challenges for a Hanukkah competition at home. They must turn eight leftover items into a meal.